Type 2 diabetes mellitus with diabetic macular edema, resolved following treatment. As with injection therapy, sometimes selfmonitoring blood glucose. Mar 30, 2017 objective to compare the effectiveness of insulin pumps with multiple daily injections for adults with type 1 diabetes, with both groups receiving equivalent training in flexible insulin treatment. Costeffectiveness of insulin pumps compared with multiple daily. Cannulas are put into the skin every few days injections. The selfmonitoring frequency was significantly higher in all age groups with insulin pump therapy compared with insulin injection therapy 6. However, an increasing number of patients are recently switching to the insulin pump therapy. Continuous glucose monitoring and insulin delivery for managing. Insulin pump therapy bests injection therapy in large study. But over time, overused sites can build up scar tissue and not work as well. Insulin pump therapy potentially allows greater control with respect to altering basal rates, with insulin infusion even being stopped for a time and tiny boluses administered at mealtimes. An illness, such as an infection or virus like mumps, measles, rubella or the flu, or another trigger, can cause the body to turn on itself, mistakenly attacking cells in the pancreas that make insulin. When my new insulin pump arrived, i decided to take a cue from katie and delay my pump hookup a. The constancy of the basal delivery allows for a nearflat blood insulin profile, adjustable at preset times to suit the changing needs of the patient throughout the day.
She signed up for a pump vacation, taking a respite from technology in favor of injections. Nov 17, 2017 mdi therapy typically consists of an injection of intermediate or longacting insulin and three injections of rapid or shortacting insulin for meals. Comparison of the insulin pump and multiple daily insulin injections. I thought i would mention the benefits i have found after using the pump for just over a year. Patients in poor gylcemic control who, within the last 4 months, initiated intensive insulin treatment a pump or multiple daily injections or plan to do so in the next. Having fewer lows able to split the dose adjusting temp basil.
External insulin pumps that deliver insulin by continuous. The insulin pump is only one piece of the big puzzle to managing diabetes. Type 1 diabetes is also called insulindependent diabetes. Association of insulin pump therapy vs insulin injection therapy. While data do show that insulin pumping can improve health outcomes, and a recent study in bmj concluded, among people with type 1 diabetes use of insulin pump therapy is associated with lower cardiovascular mortality than treatment with multiple daily insulin injections, quality of life also needs to be taken into consideration. Compared to the insulin injections, the insulin pump therapy has been shown to improve clinical. Costeffectiveness of insulin pumps compared with multiple. In type 1 diabetes, csii reduces the frequency of severe hypoglycemia compared with. Insulin is controlled by a small device a pump about the size of a pager, which can be hidden discreetly or clipped to your clothing. When comparing children on insulin pump therapy vs. Insulin pump therapy, also known as continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion csii, involves wearing a device insulin pump which provides a steady stream of insulin into your body. Insulin pumps more cost efficient than injections over long. Heller department of oncology and metabolism at the university of sheffield, insulin pump treatment may be slightly more beneficial than standard multiple daily injections when subjects are provided with similarly structured training.
If you have a hypo you can suspend the pump so the insulin has stopped. Study unveils insulin pump and injection comparison the. Insulin pumps do not achieve better blood glucose control compared to multiple daily injections, according to a study. Costeffectiveness of insulin pumps compared with multiple daily injections both. Jun 22, 2009 several other studies have examined the cost. Insulin pump therapy with cgm posted by chris stocker on september 17, 2015 in featured posts, lifestyle as someone who has lived with diabetes for over 11 years, i have experienced life with multiple daily injections mdi, as well as an insulin. Csii therapy uses rapidacting insulin insulin aspart.
Longacting insulin analogs versus insulin pump therapy for the treatment of. Research showed groups of people on both treatment regimes showed clinically relevant and long lasting decreases in hba1c, rates of severe hypoglycaemia, and improved psychological measures, although few participants achieved glucose levels currently recommended by national. An insulin pump has advantages in that it allows the wearer to take instantaneous action to help increase or decrease blood glucose levels. Oct 02, 2007 methods the dcct was a multicenter, randomized clinical trial comparing intensive vs conventional treatment in insulin dependent diabetic patients who had no to moderate nonproliferative retinopathy. Insulin pump better than injections researchers say artificial pancreas for type 1 diabetes may be reality in several years encouraging research raises new hopes that a long awaited artificial pancreas to treat patients with type 1 diabetes could be available in the u. Dumping my horrible pump switching back to injections. It may increase family flexibility and reduces the need for multiple injections. It is pertinent to ask, however, if multiple daily injection mdi regimens based on new longacting insulin analogs such as glargine and detemir have now replaced the need for csii. A cleveland clinic endocrinologist discusses the pros and cons of prescribing insulin pumps. As a result, the body makes very little insulin, or no insulin.
Type 1 diabetes is a lifelong disease with no cure and no chance of. Retinal characteristics during 1 year of insulin pump therapy in type 1 diabetes. Insulin delivery via injection and continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion via insulin pump were compared in a recent observational study to determine whether the rates of severe hypoglycemia and diabetic ketoacidosis are lower with insulin pump therapy compared with insulin injection. Although mhba1c levels were lower during continuous insulin infusion therapy the difference was not statistically significant. Sep 17, 2015 insulin pump therapy with cgm posted by chris stocker on september 17, 2015 in featured posts, lifestyle as someone who has lived with diabetes for over 11 years, i have experienced life with multiple daily injections mdi, as well as an insulin pump therapy and continuous glucose monitor cgm. Pump users also need to rotate infusion sites as well. Sep 12, 2011 a recent study has found that insulin pump therapy may be more cost effective than frequent daily insulin injections in type 2 diabetics who require large doses of insulin throughout the day. It allows for intensive insulin therapy when used in conjunction. According to phyllis wolffmcdonagh, dnp, a certified diabetes instructor, pump therapy was less expensive over the long term because the insulin was. Longacting insulin analogs versus insulin pump therapy for.
Cgdme42 nonimplantable insulin infusion and blood glucose. Insulin pump therapy or csii continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion is a treatment option for people with type 1 diabetes which replaces the need for daily injections. Injections are needed multiple daily injections vs insulin pumps some people with type 1 diabetes will be offered the choice of staying on multiple daily injections or starting on an insulin pump. Better protection an insulin pump is an external device about the size of a regular mobile phone. The pump was great for the first 2 years i had it but i have had it replaced with the same model 5x in the past 15 months and the insurance will not allow me to. Patients followed their usual routine regarding diet, insulin treatment and. Dec 27, 2010 i thought i would mention the benefits i have found after using the pump for just over a year. Sizeslim cofounders take on diabetic insulin pumps vs. What are advantages and disadvantages of insulin treatment. Insulin pumps therapy is associated with better glycemic control and fewer complications, new study suggests. Longacting insulin analogs versus insulin pump therapy. Apr 17, 2012 she signed up for a pump vacation, taking a respite from technology in favor of injections.
Complications with insulin pump therapy vs insulin injection. Overuse of a site area can also cause atrophy, a denting in of the skin. Realworld costs of continuous insulin pump therapy and. Longacting insulin analogs versus insulin pump therapy for the. Our data confirm that insulinpump therapy provides an improvement in glycemic control, which is sustained for at least seven years. Mdi therapy typically consists of an injection of intermediate or longacting insulin and three injections of rapid or shortacting insulin for meals. It is an alternative way to multiple daily injections of insulin by using insulin syringe or an insulin pen. The development of insulin pump therapy continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion csii nearly 30 years ago did much to overcome the problems of longacting insulin injections.
The use of insulinpump therapy has increased over the past 15 years due to improved pump technology, the availability of insulin analogs, and favorable results from the. Insulin replacement therapy insulin replacement therapy and type 1 and 2 diabetes. Retinal characteristics during 1 year of insulin pump therapy in type. When my new insulin pump arrived, i decided to take a cue from katie and delay my pump hookup a little.
Done with auto mode on my medtronic 670g and maybe done with my 670g. Determinants of glycemic control in type 1 diabetes during intensified therapy with multiple daily insulin injections or continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion. Total daily insulin doses were lower for pump therapy compared with injection therapy 0. Retinopathy severity was assessed in 7field stereoscopic fundus photographs taken at baseline and every 6 months.
With insulin pump therapy, you can feel more protected from hypoglycaemia compared to insulin injections. You only use one insulin, novorapid normally, and that is your background and bolus as well. Its important to know how to use the pump properly to avoid problems or address them if they occur. An insulin pump is a medical device used by people with diabetes. Notice that i did not include the fact that insulin is given by injection as a disadvantage because in my very strong opinion an opinion shared by almost everyone who treats people with. Research design and methods individuals with type 1 diabetes and pump therapy in the swedish national diabetes register ndr since 2002 were eligible. Objective to investigate realworld costs of continuous insulin pump therapy compared with multiple daily injection mdi therapy for type 1 diabetes. Methods we undertook a costutility analysis using the sheffield type 1 diabetes policy model and data from the relative effectiveness of. Jul 21, 2010 those in the study who used the insulin pump marketed by medical device maker medtronic inc. While i can take injections and have good control which i often do when i take pump breaks, i personally feel that i can finetune my needs better with an insulin pump verses injections.
Insulin pump therapy is a commonly used alternative to multiple daily injections mdi in the treatment of pediatric type 1 diabetes. Design pragmatic, multicentre, open label, parallel group, cluster randomised controlled trial relative effectiveness of pumps over mdi and structured education repose trial. On the negative side, insulin carries a high risk of low blood sugar reactions if too much is used, and many people gain weight when treated with insulin. Continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion versus multiple. The use of insulin pump therapy has increased over the past 15 years due to improved pump technology, the availability of insulin analogs, and favorable results from the. Study shows insulin pumps more effective than injections. Is insulin pump therapy better than injection for adolescents. They focused solely on hypoglycemia and ketoacidosis over an 8. Our data confirm that insulin pump therapy provides an improvement in glycemic control, which is sustained for at least seven years. The use of insulin pumps for intensive insulin therapy among patients with type 1 diabetes has substantially increased from 0.
The aim of the current study was to examine whether there are different medical and psychosocial outcomes for adolescents using mdi versus pump therapy as experienced in a naturally occurring context of self or. Association of insulin pump therapy vs insulin injection. The development of new insulin pumps is based on sophisticated technology. Some people with type 1 diabetes will be offered the choice of staying on multiple daily injections or starting on an insulin pump we look at some benefits and disadvantages of insulin pumps and multiple injections.
Proper training key to best results in both groups. Continuous insulin therapy versus multiple insulin injections. Insulin pump better than injections researchers say artificial pancreas for type 1 diabetes may be reality in several years encouraging research raises new hopes that a long awaited artificial pancreas to treat patients with type 1 diabetes could be available in. Methods we undertook a costutility analysis using the sheffield type 1 diabetes policy model and data from the relative. The site, which is the connection where the pump sends insulin into the body, can be placed in any area of the body with fatty tissue. Table 2 efficacy of insulin pump therapy compared to multiple injections with nph. Review indepth clinical information, latest medical news, and guidelines about insulin therapy, including interpretation of glucose and insulin levels, types of insulin short.
Type 1 diabetes is a lifelong disease with no cure and no chance of remission. External insulin infusion pumps and cgms maybe be combined to form. Daviss team compared outcomes for 345 children, aged 2 to 19, who were using insulin pumps to control their type 1 diabetes to a similar number of. Dec 17, 2017 sizeslim cofounders take on diabetic insulin pumps vs. Its an alternative to multiple daily injections of insulin using a syringe or pen. Insulin pump therapy is the most natural form of insulin treatment available nowaday. Today was the last straw and im ready to dump my insulin pump and move back to injections. Those in the study who used the insulin pump marketed by medical device maker medtronic inc. Insulin pump therapy continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion csii is now an established form of intensive insulin treatment. Today, about 31 percent of adults with diabetes use insulin according to the centers for disease control and prevention.
A recent study has found that insulin pump therapy may be more cost effective than frequent daily insulin injections in type 2 diabetics who require large doses of insulin throughout the day. I injected from age 5 to 21 and i had decent control without doing much work for it. Insulin pump vs injections va ny harbor health care system. Using an insulin pump to manage diabetes is more convenient than managing the disease with daily insulin injections. In diabetics, it causes serious cutaneous and especially retinal and renal. Research showed groups of people on both treatment regimes showed clinically relevant and long lasting decreases in hba1c, rates of severe hypoglycaemia, and improved psychological measures, although few participants achieved glucose levels currently recommended by. In this populationbased observational study including 30 579 young patients with type 1 diabetes, pump therapy, compared with injection. The bodys immune system attacks the cells that make insulin. Csii therapy uses rapidacting insulininsulin aspart.
329 667 1647 1137 799 935 1010 244 222 306 954 1243 965 544 12 253 1025 79 96 282 931 735 556 1417 711 469 1256 455 1617 712 1315 684 712 403 915 1590 552 1591 155 466 365 1047 368 949 898 852 929 857